THE Broadway

Customer Reviews

I waited a month to review Review by R.Perry III

Customer Service
Quality
Value
Price
Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

As a cigar enthusiast and a woodworker I genuinely admire this beautiful humidor. In to its aesthetic appeal,
it maintains a very consistent and stable temp & humidity in our currently sporadic climate of rainy then annoyingly hot the next. I seasoned for 2 weeks and it was holding a very consistent 74% and 71 degrees. After adding a dozen cigars it fell to 72% and 70 degrees. I removed the humidifier cage and even a week with no humidifier in the box, it is maintaining a 66%, 70 degrees state. The humidor came carefully packaged in bubble wrap, with a protective box, encased in more wrap inside an additional box which arrived with absolutely no dings, nicks or scratches. I HIGHLY recommend this humidor as it will fill quickly and serve me for the rest of my life until I can pass it along to my son.

PS: I opted for the digital hydrometer and solution which I also credit for the consistency and accuracy of the humidor's state.

(Posted on 6/24/23)

Simply Outstanding Review by Smoking Joe

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

The Broadway arrived double boxed and in flawless condition. This humidor holds a steady 72%. I found the mounting magnets require help to stay in place. Double stick tape works well so far. I upgraded to the digital humidistat, which is more accurate than the analog one which does not calibrate very well. The digital one has an easy calibration feature. It does not fit the mounting location which is completely enclosed, so I wonder how the analog one works since it looks like it can only measure the humidity in the wood in the lid. Maybe that is all that is required, however, my old humidor had a mount that suspended the humidistat away from the lid for free air circulation. Bottom line, I am very satisfied even with the minor drawbacks as this is a strikingly beautiful and well made humidor. (Posted on 5/20/22)

Great Review by Jimmymac

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

I love the price and think the product is excellent it replaced my old one witch was a larger and a lot pricey thanks (Posted on 5/5/22)

My second review Review by Don

Customer Service
Price
Value
Quality

I bought this humidor over 2 years ago and left a review but i wanted to add to it. This is an exceptional box, very well built, perfect finish and a very good seal. The aroma from this thing will make your mouth water when you open it. ALL my cigars go into this humidor for 90 days before i smoke them. To be honest the sticks smell so good after being in this humidor i want to eat them. I have several humidors but none of them compare to the aroma and flavor profiles of the sticks coming from the Broadway.
Its a beautiful box that holds humidity like a champ and it will take very good care of those prized cigars.
Buy with confidence (Posted on 8/17/20)

service Review by sugar

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

Just wanted to comment on the service because I ordered my humidor on a tuesday , come friday night it still has not shipped will not ship until hopefully monday. You call service and it's obvious they do not care. When you pay for expedited processing and 3 day shipping , what is the point if it takes a week for them to put your humidor in the mail. Like theres 1 person constantly on break in the warehouse waiting last minute to do everything. Extremely disappointed with service. Just hope my humidor is nice when it finally gets here one day. Certainly won't be ordering from here again reccomend you dont either ! (Posted on 5/16/20)

Humidor: Five Stars / Hygrometer: One Star Review by Lee

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

I agree with all the other reviews here that comment on the look and construction of this humidor. It's absolutely beautiful and makes an immediate statement that you're a cigar aficionado. Well-built, this humidor is fully lined in Spanish cedar and seals well. It maintains humidity perfectly and will keep your cigars fresh and tasty — but you'll only know reliably if you upgrade the analog hygrometer, which is inexpensive plastic (looks like the five-dollar hygrometer available on this site) and untrustworthy. And really, if you're going to spring for a beautiful humidor like this, you should spend a few dollars more ($20) on a digital hygrometer that you can trust. Don't get me wrong — even with my reservations about the hygrometer, I'd buy this humidor again. It's attractive, well-built, spacious, and a great value. (Posted on 12/19/19)

Fantastic Value Review by smokem

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

Bought this Broadway humidor at a deal and couldn't be happier. From the excellent packaging to the high gloss finish this thing is a win win. Quality construction with and flawless precision of fitment would make this humidor a bargain at twice the price. After the seasoning cycle I loaded it with around 50 of my prized sticks and its holding humidity like a charm. I'm going to spring for a better humidifier but with Boveda packs I'm having no issues with holding.
The hydrometer was pretty much junk which was no fault of seller but they sent one post haste to replace it and its salt testing right on the money.
This company sells good humidors and my experience with them has been 5 stars. A true 5 star company across the board.
(Posted on 10/4/19)

Superior Craftmenship Review by George

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

When this humidor arrived I was immediately impressed with the craftsmanship. It is beautiful and well made. A real bargain. (Posted on 8/19/19)

Very nice ... Review by Tom W

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

Came well packaged, is beautiful and holds humidity. I have about 70+ cigars in it. (150 is a stretch unless they are all Coronas). The hydrometer did not work but customer service took care of me. I am extremely pleased with the value this product provides. I am one happy customer! (Posted on 8/2/19)

This is a very good box Review by Joe King

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

I bough this to put my Mother ashes in, not cigars. It is a very well made box and works well for me (Posted on 8/7/18)

Well-made Humidor Review by Stan

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

Well constructed and finished. Very pleased with it. Not all humidors have Spanish cedar linings these days: this one does. Best price I found anywhere. (Posted on 4/11/18)

Excellent Review by Greg

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

The humidor arrived double boxed to avoid shipping mishapps, my 1st indication of your excellent customer service. This humidor beat ALL my expectations, it looks flawless, and seals perfectly. When I went to calibrate the hydrometer, it was already set. I love this thing. (Posted on 3/14/18)

gorgeous Review by brian

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

love my new humidor. Everyone who sees it says its just beautiful. (Posted on 1/22/18)

Best bang for your buck Review by MikeyJ

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

Beautiful finish on exterior. Dividers and tray create 5 spaces (3 on tray, 2 in bottom) to separate brands/flavors. The lock works well enough to keep out little hands and nosy buddies. (Posted on 12/8/17)

Great gift Review by Susie Q

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

This was a gift for my son and he loves it. At the time it was ordered the site said it was in stock. When it wasn't received as expected I learned it was not in stock and the company had failed to let me know. I was told that they normally contact the customer if this happens. I went ahead with the order because it was supposed to be in within a few days. I still gave them a 4 in customer service because the rep (Donna) oversaw my order at that point to make sure it would be shipped the same day it was received in inventory (expedited shipping at no cost). It was received a day before the promise date. (Posted on 7/5/17)

Shockingly superb. Review by Nikon Lee

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

I actually did not believe i could get something so phenomenal at such a low price. It is beautiful and it seals perfectly and keeps humidity perfectly. Will buy from these guys again. 100% satisfied (Posted on 3/26/17)

very happy with humidor Review by Fearless

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

After looking for a humidor for almost two months, I decided to order this one. Works great, shipped fast, well packed and is a great looking humidor. First class wed site ,would recommend to anyone. Best of all a terrific value for the price. (Posted on 3/8/17)

Great humidor at a great price! Review by Ed

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

My Broadway Humidor came on time and is a beautiful work of art! After conditioning it is now keeping my cigars perfectly! (Posted on 2/27/17)

Worth the cost , good humidor Review by Rocco

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

Real happy with the humidor , seals nice , humidy stays right around 70 , looks great quality workmanship , worth the cost , would recommend it , (Posted on 1/24/17)

Great product Review by Lynn

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

My husband just received his second Broadway humidor as a Christmas present. He loves it. He goes on the internet to find out how to prep it for his cigars. (Posted on 12/29/16)

Incredible Buy! Review by LVS

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

The photos of this humidor don't do
it justice. It's gorgeous! My husband loved it (it was a Christmas gift). Honestly, it looks like it should have cost hundreds of dollars, and my husband commented on how well-finished it was.

My only negative (and it's my own fault) is that I didn't realize how large it was. That should be a consideration if you want it for a small space. (Posted on 12/29/16)

Beautiful Review by Nicki

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

This humidor is so beautiful. I couldn't be happier with the selection. It was a gift and he absolutely loved it great quality and price (Posted on 12/27/16)

Extremely happy Review by Big Johnson

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

I upgraded with the cigar Oasis excel. You will need the short refill cartridge to make it work. I also upgraded with the cigar oasis digital hygrometer. I have had it several weeks and it is holding humidity superbly! The construction is superb and the seal is tight at the lid. The Spanish cedar veneer is thin and is my only complaint. You will not be disappointed with this humidor! I had a small issue with my order. I e-mailed them, and they called me and corrected it immediately. I will definitely order from this company again! (Posted on 12/14/16)

Extremely pleased with everything except the shipping time Review by Geby

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

Love love love the box . The beauty of the box was beyound my expectation. This is for my Granddaughter, she wants a memory box for keeping special things to her. (Posted on 12/14/16)

What a Deal Review by glennwilson

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

The humidor is even more beautiful than the pictures. Works great and I love. What deal. (Posted on 12/5/16)

Great Humidor! Review by Jack

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

After researching many sites I determined this company had the best prices. This Humidor is not only beautiful, it works perfectly in keeping my cigars at the proper humidity levels. I think I will have to buy new furniture now to match the quality look of this Humidor! (Posted on 12/2/16)

Beautiful and functional Review by Gil

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

When I ordered I was concerned that the humidor would seal tightly. I was assured it would and I am not disappointed. This is value and art. My only critique is the humidor was back ordered and I was never notified. Overall a good experience and I will purchase my next humidor here also (Posted on 11/30/16)

Beautiful Review by Dave

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

This is the best piece of furniture in my house this humidor is a piece of art. The humidifier is basic but the humidor itself you cant be beat ANYWHERE. & Packaged with so much care there was no way your humidor could get damaged. (Posted on 8/31/16)

Broadway Review by Jack

Customer Service
Price
Value
Quality

this humidor is great so far. it's a beautiful piece of furniture. I use a digital hygrometer and beads as a humidification device. it's been great holding 70% at all times. I highly recommend this humidor to anyone, beginner or novice. customer service was spot on. (Posted on 7/27/16)

Great value Review by Sparky 66

Customer Service
Price
Value
Quality

Easy enough to order and have drop shipped as a gift. Would have appreciated an email when it shipped incomplete..... missing hygrometer upgrade.
Had to contact recipient to see if the other accessories came with the unit and then emailed and phoned to figure out what happened. Free delivery and great quality is what I understand from the recipient.
Overall very happy
(Posted on 7/12/16)

Works great Review by dustin

Customer Service
Price
Value
Quality

Humidor works great and holds at 70% no problem.
My only issue with it is a rattle noise in the lid when I open and close it.
I was going to return it, but I figured I could live with the rattle and I also didn't want to have to wait for another one to be sent. (Posted on 5/25/16)

Broadway Review by Jr

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

Very nice box and very well constructed. I am a happy customer. (Posted on 4/25/16)

Very good Review by Carl hansley

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

I wish the velcro would have stuck better or had more or larger pieces I have to go to Home Depot to buy extra to make the moisture thing stay up or it falls down other than that it's wonderful unit. (Posted on 3/3/16)

Excellent deal Review by Ben

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

Excellent Humidor. Very nice construction and finish. NO issues from the side handle penetrations of the box, holds humidity like a CHAMP. Quick responses from 1st Class Cigar Humidors meant this deal was done in hours after offering my price. NO better deal for $89 including shipping.. (Posted on 2/5/16)

great purchase Review by Lis

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

My husband said I hit a homerun. The quality is great and definitely a fantastic buy! (Posted on 2/4/16)

Gift Review by LYNN50

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

I purchased this as a Christmas gift for my husband. He is happy with it. Unfortunately, I also ordered the monogrammed plate with his initals and never received it. (Posted on 2/3/16)

excellent Review by Chip

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

Absolutely beautiful piece of furniture. Great price. I don't like the cheap hygrometer it came with. In fact it fell off after the first day but I had a replacement and the quality of the humidor lets me overlook those flaw. (Posted on 2/3/16)

Christmas Gift Review by Lynn

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

I bought this as a Christmas gift for my husband. He seems pleased with it. It arrived in a timely fashion and in good condition. However, it was supposed to have a monogrammed plate with it but I never received it. Pretty disappointing since it was a gift. (Posted on 2/2/16)

First Class Value! Review by DeeDee

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

I bought this humidor as a gift for my husband. He is a cigar aficionado, but only had small humidors to store them in. He absolutely loves it! It maintains the humidity perfectly, and has lots of room for his favorite cigars. The engraved nameplate added just the perfect touch. I would recommend this humidor to anyone. (Posted on 2/2/16)

Best deal on Net ! Review by Louthegolfer

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

THE Broadway is by far the best 150 cigar humidor for the price, especially when you utilize the "Name your price" feature. Very well built, tight seal, decent hygrometer and the humidifier. My wife didn't believe me when I told her what I paid for it, thought I was hiding something ! (Posted on 10/5/15)

Beautiful craftsmanship Review by Carson

Value
Quality
Customer Service
Price

This product was on back order and was offered a substitute. It was worth waiting 3 weeks for it.
(Posted on 8/5/15)

Very pleased Review by George

Customer Service
Price
Value
Quality

With The Broadway out of stock, customer service recommended the Santa Barbara (Stetson). It is equally as beautiful but I had a small concern with the tight closure. I ended up sanding some of the cedar 'strip' that seals the lid to the bottom section. Once I did that, the lid opens much easier but still has a good seal. It holds the humidity perfectly. Anyone can line a box with cedar, but the thing that "makes" this humidor is the way is looks. It's like a piece of furniture....with a function. (Posted on 7/1/15)

Gorgeous Review by Patrick B

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

The pics of the humidor seen online don't truly show how gorgeous this humidor is in your home. It looks like a much more expensive humidor. (Posted on 5/19/15)

Works perfectly Review by Butcher156

Price
Value
Quality
Customer Service

I recently purchased this humidor along with an upgraded humidifier, the cigar oasis excel. The humidor is a constant 70 percent humidity and maintenance in minimal. I keep between 25 and 40 cigars in it and they are all in great smoking condition. I highly recommend. Also the humifier upgrade is a must. (Posted on 5/11/15)

On The Broadway Review by Mr. Dent

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

Very nice humidor! You will differently need too age it well before adding your cigars. Well worth the price!! Thanks 1st Class Cigar Humidors.... Delivered in a air tight shipping was the icing on the cake (Posted on 4/7/15)

thank you Review by tia

Quality
Customer Service
Price
Value

It is beautiful. Cant wait to see my husbands face at Christmas time. (Posted on 12/9/14)